27 Jul 2016 220 views
supporter of
atom rss 1.0 rss 2.0
web browser google del.icio.us digg technorati
| lost password
birth date
photoblog image Masada 2
Masada 2|

Masada 2


In my previous posting (Monday), I introduced Masada and mentioned the First Jewish-Roman war or Great Rebellion. Well, today's posting is about how the war ended. In the picture you see the Negev desert to the east (roughly), from the top of Masada. In the middle there is a ramp, coming up to where I stand on top. This is what remains of the siege ramp built by the Romans, to conquer Masada.


When King Herod had the fortress of Masada built, he achieved a number architectural and engineering feats. Since my posting is about that last battle, I will not be showing pictures of the ruins and what remained of fortress, nor provide information on what made up the fortress. You may read up Wiki, that provides good info and some pictures, if so interested.


In 66 AD, during the First Jewish-Roman war, the Roman unit stationed at Masada was rused and overpowered by Zealots under leadership of Eleazar ben Ya'ir. In 70 AD, Jerusalem fell and was destroyed by the Romans. After this, some more Zealots joined those on Masada. They numbered almost 1,000 people, including men, women and children. On Masada, they held out for three years, raiding and harassing the Romans.


By 72 AD, the Romans with 15,000 people, including 9,000 soldiers, laid siege to Masada. At some stage, they decided that enough is enough and they started to build a ramp to access the top of Masada. The builders were met with stones from the top. The Romans replied by using Jewish labour in the front positions. The Zealots felt they shouldn't be killing their own people, so they allowed the building to continue. When the Romans started to laboriously move a battering ram up the ramp in 73 AD, the besieged knew the end was near. They also knew by then, that no other Jews will join them. They further knew that the Romans will not be kind to them. Men will be killed and probably in some horrible way, while women and children will become harlots and slaves, to the Romans. The besieged decided that this is not what they want, so they arrived at a pact.


Everything they posessed and the buildings, were burned down, to deny the Romans their wealth. The foodstores were left standing with the foodstuff in it. They wanted posterity to know they were not starved. Then 10 men was chosen and as part of the suicide pact, they killed everyone (so they thought) and with the 10 remaining, one was chosen to kill the others and then commit suicide. Committing suicide is against the Jewish religion - so in this way, only the last guy sinned.


When the Romans finally breached the wall, they reported that they entered a citadel of death. They later discovered two women and five children hidden in a water cistern. They told the story of the pact and repeated Eleazer's speech, which ended with: " ... We were the very first that revolted, and we are the last to fight against them; and I cannot but esteem it as a favor that God has granted us, that it is still in our power to die bravely, and in a state of freedom."


The picture below, was taken to the right of the main picture. It shows the remains of where the Romans were encamped, during the siege. There are more of these remains below the cliffs in the picture.


comments (13)

  • Ray
  • Not United States
  • 27 Jul 2016, 01:08
The dramatic vista matches your colourful narrative, Louis, and makes the post memorable in a very stark manner.
Louis: Thank you, Ray. I like deserts for some reason.
  • Martine
  • France
  • 27 Jul 2016, 06:12
On dirait un paysage lunaire.
Louis: Elle ressemble à ça. Merci, Martine.
  • Chris
  • England
  • 27 Jul 2016, 07:24
Ye gods isn't history grim sometimes. Let us hope those few survivors were allowed to live..
Louis: Grim stuff still happens, yes. Most likely those women and children would have ended up as slaves.
  • Philine
  • United States
  • 27 Jul 2016, 07:25
The desert is always fascinating.
Louis: I agree, Philine
  • Lisl
  • Bath, England
  • 27 Jul 2016, 07:42
Imagine trying to hold out here, Louis
Louis: The fortress was very well stocked, Lisl. They built channels in the side of the mountain, feeding water cisterns when it rained. The place stood for many years before the siege - so, they had enough water. Many grain silo's provided food and they used grain to trap birds for fresh meat. The use of Jewish labour on the ramp, was the downfall of the Zealots.
What a sight Louis! Thank you for the history words.
Louis: Thank you Richard.
Crumbs Louis, you are bringing history to life with your words and pictures.
Louis: Thank you, gutteridge. It was quite an experience to be there.
What a sad, sad story. Is this largest structure shown in both photos, a solar panel, a building, or what? What is the pattern in the rock to the right of that?
Louis: They are huge solar panels. In the main picture, you can see a guest house, not too far from the solar installation. The pattern is the stone walls that is left from one of the Roman encampments, from during the siege. Another such pattern is the square to the front of the panels. Sad, indeed, Mary.
It is all so barren but also quite beautiful in a strange sort of way. To have battles there it seems there would have be no way to conceal the armies although I guess at that time it would all have been hand to hand fighting.
Louis: An army on the march, kicks up a lot of dust - no concealment. Sitting on top, the defenders saw everything the Romans did - but they were out of reach, so they couldn't do a thing with their knowledge, except wait. The number advantage doesn't always pan out - see this one http://louis.shutterchance.com/theme/1-all-themes/image/2007/06/21/hungarian-history/
Looks like the world has always been mad.
Louis: In terms of madness, not a lot has chaned, Bill.
History lies beneath you...
Louis: Very true, Larry. Thank you.
it's such a stark landscape Louis... it seems that it wasn't worth having the Great Rebellion over this place....petersmile
Louis: The rebellion was all about the Judea state. The action at Masada was just the last stand. The amazing thing to me, is that people are still living in this desert, while the rest of the country is not as inhospitable.
It's quite a barren landscape, isn't it?
Louis: The amazing thing to me, is that people are still living in this desert, while the rest of the country is not as inhospitable, Elizabeth.

Leave a comment

must fill in
[stop comment form]
for this photo I'm in a any and all comments icon ShMood©
camera COOLPIX P500
exposure mode full manual
shutterspeed 1/999.99s
aperture f/4.5
sensitivity ISO160
focal length 4.0mm
Brugge lace makingBrugge lace maki...
Masada 3Masada 3
Masada 1Masada 1